Tuesday, November 24, 2009

SOMEBODY GET ME A DOCTOR...who knows evolution ;)

I think EVERYTHING should be looked at under the microscope of evolution. I think we could come up with better air conditioners, cars, medicines...hell, everything could be better if we approached from a "natural selection" attitude.

Answering the question about medicine needing an evolutionary prospective...I do. I often times think that we (humans) look to much into the short-term and not into the long. By looking at WHY human immune systems react the way they do, not just HOW they react may lead to better methods of dealing with illness. The first thing I would like to see is a shift away from the stigma attached to evolution education. The story about some med students complaining that evolution was "forced on them" is sad. Some aspects of ecology are uncomfortable for me, but as a scientist I explore them and try to gain an understanding. Avoiding evolution, or demonizing it, must not lead to a well rounded scientific mind. I would love to know if my doctor had any kind of evolutionary education before I become a patient. If more people understood evolution, I'm betting they would too. So, education becomes priority number 1.

Understanding human past (and disease past) seems crucial to certain situations. I think doctors could better prescribe less invasive treatments, or more natural ones, if they have an understanding of WHY humans react like they do...take the breast cancer example. As a high school teacher, I shudder at the idea of teens becoming pregnant as a method for fighting breast cancer (not to mention the economic and environmental impact of all those babies!), but knowing how humans evolved could lead to better PREVENTATIVE measures over time.

I think dealing with common ailments like cough and fever might be better handled if doctors AND patients had more knowledge about WHY cough and fever are beneficial. However, we live in an "immediate cure" world and patience and time aren't things we value (some of us do...but many in society want it NOW).

As for the analogy, I WOULD want my mechanic to know the history and evolution of the car I have. Perhaps the older model had a better solution for a problem that the mechanic faces now. If the mechanic understands the evolution of a system, perhaps (s)he could fix the problem quicker/easier/cheaper than if simply going on training. I'm not saying that you HAVE to have evolutionary knowledge to fix it, but it surely must be an advantage.

Here is an article on engineers using Darwin's principle of natural selection for designing analog circuits using Genetic Algorithms. Kinda advanced for my knowledge base of electronics, but I hope it makes my point that everything could be made better through evolution!

www.mrc.uidaho.edu/~knoren/GAs/B-159_paper.PDF

4 comments:

  1. I agree with you that people must understand evolution and especially in the scientific community, too. How do those who believe or disagree with evolution can state that perhaps God created the Earth and all past and present species through evolution?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your entry is very good however, I just don't think that doctors knowing evolution would help anymore then what they know now. I think it's important for scientist to know the evolution behind everything because they are the ones that are creating new vaccines and treatments.

    ReplyDelete
  3. K.C.,

    I guess we can agree to disagree...I guess I would rather have a doctor that has a greater understanding of the machine that is the human body, and I would like to think that would make them a better problem solver. I agree that scientists would need the evolutionary knowledge that you describe, but I would hate to think that someone with a medical degree would just be someone who is good at memorizing symptoms, adds them together and writes a prescription (I've actually had some doctors that do just that). Honestly, that is what webmd.com is for, without the prescription. Medicine should focus on all aspects of the human machine, not just the current mechanics. But like I said, we can agree to disagree.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with your entry. I don't think we need to know everything about evolution but I do believe that even knowing somewhat about it can help doctors. Maybe even more than we know.

    ReplyDelete